The Book of Christians

BOOK IV, CHAPTER FIVE

SACRAMENTS IMPART NO LIFE

OUTSIDE THE TRUE CHURCH


For God doth not give the Spirit by measure. (St. John 3:34)

The Sacraments, which some people keep and use outside the unity of Christ, are able to preserve the appearance of piety; but the invisible and spiritual virtue of true piety cannot abide there any more than feeling can remain in an amputated part of your body. (Pope Leo XIII) 1

The Church alone possesses the beneficial use of the Sacraments, the efficacious instruments of grace. (Catechism of Trent) 2

Cut off from the Body into which alone the graces of Christ flow, you are deprived of the benefit of all Sacraments. (St. Edmund Campion) 3

The Gentiles have churches, and scriptures, and sacrifices, and teachers, and books, and a partial knowledge of God; nevertheless, no one on earth possesses the grace and operation of the Holy Spirit except those who have been rightly baptized by faith in the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. (Bl. Jerome of Jerusalem) 4

Hold most firmly, and never doubt in the least, that outside the Catholic Church the Sacrament of Baptism cannot be of any profit; nay, just as within the Church salvation is conferred through the Sacrament of Baptism upon those who believe rightly, so too, outside the Catholic Church, ruin is heaped up for those who were baptized by that same Baptism, if they do not return to the Church. (St. Fulgentius) 5

There is no salvation outside the Church, and therefore whatever things of the Church are had outside the Church do not avail unto salvation. (St. Augustine) 6

Anyone who receives the Sacrament of Baptism, whether in the Catholic Church or in a heretical or schismatic church, receives the whole Sacrament; however, he will not have salvation if he has that Sacrament outside the Catholic Church. Eternal life can never in any way be obtained by anyone who, with the Sacrament of Baptism, remains a stranger to the Catholic Church. Hold most firmly and never doubt in the least that no person baptized outside the Catholic Church can become a partaker of eternal life if, before the end of this earthly life, he has not returned, and been incorporated into the Catholic Church. (St. Fulgentius) 7

Some men can receive Baptism outside the Church, but no one can either receive or possess salvation outside the Church. For the water of the Church is salutary and holy for those who use it well, but outside the Church no one can use it well. (St. Augustine) 8

There are many heresies which utilize the words of Baptism, but not in a proper sense, nor with sound faith; and, in consequence, the water which they pour is unprofitable, so that he who is sprinkled by them is polluted rather than redeemed. (St. Athanasius) 9

Although among heretics and schismatics there is the same Baptism, nevertheless, remission of sins is not operative among them because of the rottenness of discord and wickedness of dissension. (St. Augustine) 10

Without a doubt, the forgiveness of sins is the work of the Holy Spirit and is granted by God, but not independently of the Church founded by Jesus Christ for the salvation of all men. (Antipope John Paul II) 11

Besides a desire to be baptized, faith is also necessary to obtain the grace of the Sacrament. Our Lord said: "He who believes and is baptized shall be saved" (Mk. 16:16). (Catechism of Trent) 12

Therefore, Baptism without faith avails nothing. If anyone without the right faith receives Baptism outside the Church, he does not receive it untosalvation. Men can receive the Baptism of the Church outside her fold, but no one can receive or keep the salvation of the blessed outside the Church. (St. Thomas Aquinas) 13

Baptism does not profit a man outside unity with the Church, for many heretics also possess this Sacrament, but not the fruits of salvation. Children baptized in other communions cease to be members of the Church when, after reaching the age of reason, they make formal profession of heresy, as, for example, by receiving communion in a non-Catholic church. (St. Augustine) 14

They no longer have the Sacraments, with the exception of Baptism; a fruitful baptism for children, provided that, once the age of reason is reached, they do not embrace the schism. (Pope Leo XIII) 15

Heretics and schismatics place an obstacle to God's grace by their sins of infidelity and schism in which they actually persevere. (St. Robert Bellarmine) 16

The Church is built on the Rock of Peter, and he who eats the Lamb outside this holy dwelling has no part with God. (Ven. Pope Pius IX) 17

Outside the unity of faith and love which makes us members of the Church, no one can be saved; hence, if the Sacraments are received outside the Church, they are not effective for salvation even though they be true Sacraments. However, they can become useful if a person returns to Holy Mother the Church, the solitary Spouse of Christ, whose sons alone Christ considers worthy of eternal inheritance. (St. Bonaventure) 18

REFERENCES

BOOK IV, CHAPTER FIVE


1. Leo XIII: "Exima Nos Laetitia," PTC:526

2. Catechism: COT p.105

3. Edmund: LFS p.175

4. Jerome: LAF vol.VII, p.528-529; FOC cf. p.286

5. Fulgentius: "On Faith, To Peter," LXXIX, JUR vol.III:2273

6. Augustine: "On Baptism, Against the Donatists," Bk.IV, no. 24; PL 43:107; CSL vol.LI; FOC p.309, no.1

7. Fulgentius: Op. cit., JUR vol.III:2269, 2274; PL 65: 671

8. Augustine: Op. cit., Bk.IV, ch.1, no.1; ch.2, no.2, CSL vol. LI (1908); "Commentary on John," tract VI, no.13, 14; PL 35

9. Athanasius: "Discourse Against the Arians," Bk.II, ch.18, no. 42-43; PG 26

10. Augustine: "On Baptism," Bk.III:13, 18 and VI:9, 14, JUR vol. III:1625 and 1637

11. John Paul II: The Wanderer, May 14, 1992, p.10, col.4

12. Catechism: COT p.181

13. Thomas: STL III, Q.68, art.8

14. Augustine: Sermon VIII, PL 46:838; SS vol.IV, p.254 ff.

15. Leo XIII: "Exima Nos Laetitia," PTC:526

16. Robert: "On the Sacrament of Baptism," Bk.I, ch.6

17. Pius IX: "Multis Gravibus.," PTC:229; "Amantiss.," PTC:236

18. Bonaventure: BRE Bk. VI, ch.5:4